LawPhilosophyMedicine

Why Is Medical Consent Personal?

A. Pielak

2025.6.1Journal of Law and Medicine

tlooto Summary

It is argued that based on the general legal provisions on proxy, the patient cannot make medical decisions by a representative, therefore, informed consent is of a personal nature.

Abstract

The article engages with the nature of medical consent in the context of a patient's proxy granted in case of decision-making capacity. It argues that based on the general legal provisions on proxy, the patient cannot make medical decisions by a representative. Therefore, informed consent is of a personal nature. The thesis is supported by a comparative-legal analysis of selected continental and common law systems, Kant's and Mill's concept of autonomy, and functional reasoning.

Citation format

PIELAK, A. Why is medical consent personal? Journal of Law and Medicine, 2025, 32 1: 85–93.