Andreas Freivogel

2024DIALECTICA

DOI: 10.48106/dial.v78.i4.01

Abstract

Abstract I address a common objection against reflective equilibrium, viz. that it is overly conservative because it does not spur thoroughgoing revisions. I operationalise informal aspects of conservativity in a formal model of reflective equilibrium. This allows for data exploration by means of computer simulation. The results show that the formal model of reflective equilibrium performs better than a conservative baseline. I conclude from this that reflective equilibrium offers the means to escape the charge of conservativity if the under-appreciated facet of systematisation is given due weight.

Citation format

FREIVOGEL, Andreas. Is reflective equilibrium overly conservative? DIALECTICA, 2024.